NLT
		   logo and link to NLT home page 
Literacy changes lives

Modern Languages

This section focuses on new developments and research into the teaching of modern languages (other than English) in UK schools. 

News update

Government approaches

Background information

Statistics

Approaches in other countries

Useful organisations

News update


National Languages Strategy

The National Languages Strategy aims to boost Britain's poor record on languages by involving young children.

Children's progress will be assessed against a new scale similar to music grades. The Government wants to expand the number of foreign language assistants, language undergraduates and volunteers from the community going into primaries to teach under supervision. These assistants will be expected to take a short training course, similar to teaching English as a foreign language (TEFL) courses.

The main points of the strategy are:

  • Languages optional at 14
  • Every primary to have a languages coordinator by 2010
  • Languages should be introduced to seven-year-olds in class time by 2010
  • A new grading system for language learners to sit alongside existing qualifications
  • A new qualification of teaching a foreign language to help language speakers to work in classrooms
  • Employers to be encouraged to support language learning


(TES, 20 December 2002)


Key statistics about modern foreign language teaching in England

  • Only about 21% of primary schools offer some form of language teaching
  • The most frequently cited reason schools stop teaching modern languages is that fulfilling the statutory requirements of the national curriculum is a higher priority
  • The time allocated to language teaching increases through the primary years, reaching an average peak of one hour a week in independent schools and 45 minutes in state schools
  • Most of those teaching languages in primary schools do not have languages as their main responsibility
  • The most frequently taught languages in primary schools are in order: French, German, Spanish and Italian
  • Many primaries have no link with their local secondaries for language teaching

(Source: Findings from the most recent QCA report (2000) on the language teaching available to key stage 2 pupils - seven to 11-year-olds)


Useful organisations 

Centre for Information on Language teaching
(CILT) and the National Advisory Centre for Early
Language Learning
CILT focuses on the professional development of modern foreign language teaching.
Both contactable at: 20 Bedfordbury, London WC2N 4LB. Tel: 020 7379 5101. Website: www.cilt.org.uk and www.nacell.org.uk

Update

Languages stutter to a rethink

The Government is ready to backtrack on its controversial decision to allow pupils to drop all foreign languages at age 14. Alan Johnson, the education secretary, admitted he is "re-thinking" the optional status of foreign languages after a sharp decline in the number of pupils studying them since 2004 when they stopped being compulsory.

(TES, 15 September 2006)


Primary pupils showing passion for languages

The Department for Education and Skills (DfES) is hoping that the end of compulsory language teaching in secondary schools will lead to a renaissance in linguistic ability in a nation notoriously adverse to acquiring a foreign tongue. The DfESs decision to scrap compulsory language lessons for the over-14s from 2004 caused an outcry, however, convinced that younger children are more receptive to foreign languages than older pupils, it decided to introduce language teaching in primary schools instead.

The majority of children at 1,400 primaries that introduced a language, usually French, in a pilot scheme say that they enjoyed the experience so much that they want to carry on with it in secondary school. By 2010 all seven to 11 year-olds will be entitled to learn at least one foreign language in school.

60% of pupils in secondary schools are dropping languages, however, where pupils do decide to continue studying languages beyond the age of 14, they are doing better. The A* to C pass rate rose by seven percentage points in 2005.

There has also been a growing interest in non-European languages, with a 35% increase from 2003 to 2005 in the number of entries for Mandarin at GCSE. The number of entries for Arabic at GCSE rose from 1,854 in 2004 to 2,183 in 2005.

(The Times, 11 August 2006)


Britons at bottom of table for learning a foreign language

Almost two in three Britons are unable to speak a language other than English, a survey for the European Commission showed. 62% of respondents from the UK admitted they could not speak any language other than their mother tongue. This compared with an average of 44% across the EU and just 1% in Luxembourg, the top-ranking country.

Only Ireland, with 66%, outdid Britain, but the situation is complicated there because 11% of the population count Irish as their mother tongue - and virtually all of those can also speak English.

About 700 people were interviewed in every EU country in November and December 2005 for the report, Europeans and their Languages. The survey monitored progress towards the EU target for all citizens to speak two languages in addition to their mother tongue. But the study found only 38% of Britons spoke at least one foreign language, 18% at least two, and 6% at least three. This compared with an EU average of 56% speaking at least one foreign language, 28% at least two, and 11% at least three.

The survey also confirmed that English was the most widely-spoken foreign language throughout Europe, with 51% of EU citizens able to hold a conversation in English.

(Independent, 23 February 2006)


Language decline troubles heads

Boring lessons and exacting standards are the chief reasons teenagers shun modern languages, reports Michael Shaw. Only a fifth of 15-year-olds now learn a foreign language, a survey published today shows.

Headteachers blame a lack of high-quality language teachers and say uninspiring lessons are putting teenagers off. The Government's decision to make the subject non-compulsory is only partly at fault.

The survey by the Secondary Heads Association highlights the sharp drop in take-up of modern languages since the Government made the subject non-compulsory for over-14s a year ago. Its findings are more alarming than a survey last November by Cilt, the National Centre for Languages, which suggested that more than a third of teenagers were abandoning languages.

(TES, 28 October 2005)


Wealth of languages ignored in Wales

Survey shows the richness of community bilingualism but few opportunities to take exams. Karen Thornton reports

At least 93 languages other than English and Welsh are spoken by more than 8,000 pupils across Wales, according to a new survey. But outside of Cardiff there is little provision for children to study their family language to exam level, either in school or after lessons.

CILT Cymru, the national centre for languages in Wales, is hoping the survey findings will encourage more local authorities and schools to work together to provide joint lessons and exam opportunities for young people.

At present, some children in Flintshire travel to Chester for Arabic lessons and to Liverpool for Cantonese.

Ceri James, director of CILT Cymru, said: "One of the problems is there are lots of languages and learners out there. But except for some schools in Cardiff, it is difficult to arrange any provision or exam entries.

"Schools and local education authorities have to rationalise and collaborate.

"We are always saying Britain is very poor on learning languages but we have this big native resource here that is ignored. The armed forces and other employers are looking for people with Arabic and Urdu skills.

"If children can get recognition for their abilities via qualifications, they might have more confidence to use their languages in work," he added.

The survey figures are believed to be underestimates because only 13 out of Wales's 22 LEAs were able to provide information about community languages.

(TES Cymru, 23 September 2005)


Languages boost for pupils at 7

Primary pupils are to be taught a foreign language for at least an hour a week from the age of seven after a pilot study proved successful. The majority of pupils at the 1,400 primaries which introduced a language - usually French - said they enjoyed the experience and wanted to carry on with it at secondary school, according to a report published by the Department for Education and Skills.

Lord Adonis, the schools minister, announced an extra £49.5 million for training next year in preparation for 2010 when all primaries will be expected to teach at least one foreign language.

(Telegraph, 19 October 2005)


Teaching community languages may improve British foreign language slump

A celebration of community languages in schools is one way of ridding Britain of its reputation as the world's language "dunce" and promoting better relations between different ethnic groups, education experts believe.

They say gloom over the slump in take-up of traditional foreign languages in secondary schools is masking a success story over the learning of ethnic minority languages. At least 15 foreign languages have shown an increase in take-up at A-level during the past four years, all spoken by ethnic minority groups in the UK.

In addition, after-school clubs in state schools teach a total of 61 ethnic minority languages to their pupils.

The rise in A-level take-up covers languages such as Chinese and Russian - study of which is considered important for the future health of the economy - as well as Asian languages including Urdu and Gujarati. Just before this year's A-level results were announced, Sir Digby Jones, director-general of the Confederation of British Industry, said it was essential for Britain's world business links for more pupils to start studying these languages so tomorrow's business leaders could pull off deals in these countries.

Research for the Centre for Information on Language Teaching (Cilt), published yesterday, shows a revolution in the take-up of non-traditional languages in secondary schools. The number of students taking A-level in Chinese has increased from 1,375 to 2,062 since 2001, Russian from 469 to 636 and Urdu from 485 to 739.

Experts say promoting ethnic minority languages could also persuade native English speakers to take an interest in them. Cilt's research, by the University of Stirling, found the linguistic map of Britain was changing, with multi-lingualism spreading from typically multi-ethnic areas to more "traditional" parts. In Wrexham, for instance, a total of 25 home languages are now spoken, including Portuguese, Polish, Tagalog and Shona.

(Independent, 23 September 2005)


Slump in French and German A-levels worries business

The number of teenagers who took French and German at A level fell in 2005 to the lowest yet, despite more students entering for exams overall than ever before. The numbers studying maths and science recovered slightly. Just 14,484 pupils studied French and 5,901 studied German.

Business leaders cautioned that trade would be harmed unless the decline were reversed, as Britain would be increasingly unable to win deals abroad. However, the Government insisted that with a total rise overall of 473 people studying languages - including Spanish, Italian, Mandarin and Russian - students are simply choosing different courses.

Amid the celebration of the 23rd year-on-year increase in A-level passes to 96.2% and A grades up to 22.8%, Ellie Johnson Searle, director of the Joint Council for Qualifications, admitted that the outlook for the study of European languages was not so rosy. "It's a stark picture for French," she admitted, adding: "Those figures have halved in the past ten years."

Since 1992, the number studying French A level has dropped by nearly two thirds, from 31,261. For German, the drop is a third. However, as the interest in Spain and the so-called Beckham effect show no signs of wearing off, Spanish overtook German for the first time with 6,230 entries at A level.
At the same time, more than 2,000 students took Mandarin and those taking AS level rose by almost 10% to 3,596.

Neil Bentley, the head of skills and employment for the CBI, acknowledged the modest rise but said that in general the low numbers were a worrying sign of complacency. He said: "With only 4% studying them, it underlines a move away from speaking foreign languages, back to a British arrogance where English is the only language of use.But in reality just talking English doesn't cut the mustard, so if we don't have young people with language skills, we're not going to win the deals."

(Times, 19 August 2005)

Primary project turns pupils into polyglots

Not many primary pupils can speak French, German, Latin, Japanese, Spanish and Punjabi. But researchers hope these polyglot pupils will leap ahead when they settle down to learn one language at secondary school. A three-year project teaches 365 primary children a term each of six languages during Years 5 and 6. They then have their progress monitored during Year 7 at secondary school.

The aim, according to director Peter Downes, is to see whether language awareness at an early age can accelerate the learning of a specific language later on. "We are testing the hypothesis that it's better for children in primary school to learn about languages than to learn one specific language for a number of years," said Mr Downes, retired head of Hinchingbrooke school, Huntingdon, and a former president of the Association for Language Learning.

The £150,000 project, which started last Christmas, involves 15 classes in nine schools from Cambridgeshire, Northamptonshire, Derbyshire and Staffordshire. It is funded by the Esmee Fairbairn Foundation, directed by the Secondary Heads Association, and will be evaluated by Manchester University in 2007. Pupils will learn basic phrases in all languages, but will also look at more general concepts such as word gender, how you learn a language, and the ways different languages use word order or represent sounds. Mr Downes said that the advantage of language awareness over a specific language is that it benefits pupils starting any language at secondary school.

(TES, 12 August 2005)


German spelling reform

Eating spaghetti and tuna fish on a boat trip with a ballet dancer will never be the same again. Not in Germany, at least, where a spelling reform comes into effect this week designed to simplify a language that for centuries has baffled foreigners, and in particular English-speakers. Mark Twain, tortured by the language, said: "If it is to remain as it is, it ought to be gently and reverently set aside among the dead languages, for only the dead have the time to learn it."

The reformers have taken Twain's advice to heart and have tried to introduce some logic in German spelling. The aim is to make it more accessible not only to the likes of Mark Twain (who, being dead, has presumably come closer to mastering the lingo) but also to immigrant children.

The changes, which apply also to Austria and Switzerland, have provoked uproar in the press. Many newspapers, from Die Welt to Der Spiegel, are refusing to comply with the new rules. Parents are upset, worried that their children will be marked down by over- zealous teachers. Marcel Reich-Ranicki, Germany's leading literary critic, describes it as a "national catastrophe".

The actual reform seems hardly worth the fuss. The silent "h" is dropped. Spaghetti becomes spagetti. Tuna fish, currently Thunfisch, becomes Tunfisch. Compound nouns, so beloved of the German language, will be spelt according to logical rather than aesthetic principles. Ballet dancer is now spelled Balletttänzer with three "T" letters in the middle. Until this week it was all right to drop one of those ts. The same goes for the boat trip (Schifffahrt) and, just in time for the 2006 World Cup in Germany, an international football game, Fußballländerspiel.

The real problem is that the reforms have come from above, worked out by a group of linguistic scholars meeting behind closed doors and sponsored by the Government. Die Welt complained yesterday that its reporter had three times been thrown out of a room where the master spellers were deliberating.
One thing is for sure. Mark Twain's favourite hobbyhorse, the sheer length of German compound nouns, has not been reined in. His treasured word was Waffenstillstandsunterhandlungen (ceasefire talks) and it appeared intact again in the German press, seemingly unbattered by time or reform.

(Times, 3 August 2005)


Welsh bid to halt language teaching isolation

English, Welsh and French teachers are to work together in a scheme aimed at laying the foundations for a trilingual Wales. It is hoped the project, involving 16 schools or school clusters from across the country, will also end the tradition of secondary language departments working in isolation. The triple literacy action research project, run by CILT Cymru, the Assembly government-funded national languages centre, is due to start in November 2005. It is based on the theory that understanding grammatical similarities between different languages can aid learning. For example, a Welsh teacher could explain to pupils how adjectives in French generally come after the noun - as in Welsh. Everyday teaching duties, such as reading the register, could also be undertaken in different languages.

In addition to bringing secondary language departments together, the scheme - aimed at five to 14-year-olds - should ensure a smooth transition from primary to secondary for young language learners.

(TES Cymru, 29 July 2005)


Fairy tales used in primary schools to teach foreign languages

At Rockcliffe primary school in Cumbria, fairy tales and nursery rhymes are being used to introduce children as young as five to modern foreign languages. Youngsters pick up through "music" of other languages through listening and identifying words. The idea is to move away from the tradition of "My name is…" and "I live in…" introduction to language learning.

The scheme, which won the European Union's European Award for languages, is being used by Helen Kent, a German teacher at Trinity Specialist Language College, in Carlisle. Mrs Kent co-ordinates a team of teachers who visit nine feeder primaries several times a week to instil an interest in languages among young children.

This approach works particularly well in German, she says, because syntax is so different. "Once children become familiar with the natural flow of a language, it is not so daunting to them when they move on to aspects such as sentence structure," Mrs Kent said. "We do this by introducing characters from stories and the settings they are based in, such as castles or forests. Many of these themes recur, so through repetition children learn words and we also introduce actions."

(TES, 29 July 2005)


Ofsted recommends foreign language training for teachers

A project to boost primary foreign language learning has succeeded, despite the need for extra staff training and uncertainty over funding, inspectors have said. Ofsted's evaluation of schools in 10 pathfinder local authorities found that only 43% of primaries were able to offer a foreign language to seven to 11-year-olds. Of that 43%, half taught languages very well, said inspectors. Most pupils were confident speakers and their listening skills were very good but reading and writing skills were underdeveloped, the report said.

The quality of teaching was at least satisfactory in almost all schools, but many staff needed further training to challenge older pupils. "Teachers' linguistic competence was at least adequate, although many needed further training to teach at a higher level. Individual lessons were planned well, but few teachers had a clear sense of longer-term learning outcomes," said the report.

Implementing Language Entitlement at primary school: an Evaluation of Progress in 10 Pathfinder LEAs; and Could They Do Even Better? The Writing of Advanced Bilingual Learners of English at Key Stage 2 are available from www.ofsted.gov.uk

(TES, 15 July 2005)


Why adults find it hard to learn languages

Adults find it harder to learn new languages than children but age is not to blame, says a study. Instead of language skills deteriorating with age, as was once thought, the brain becomes better at filtering out sounds which are not needed in the native tongue. As a result, adults do not recognise sounds which are vital to other languages because they have lost their childhood ability to hear small sound differences. Paul Iverson, who wrote the report presented at a London conference, believes that adult brains can be retrained to pick up foreign sounds more easily, helping to find new ways to speak other languages.

(Telegraph, 15 June 2005)


Language specialists to reap dividends

Schools are to receive financial rewards for encouraging pupils to study modern languages at GCSE and A level. The extra investment was announced as Ofsted, the schools inspectorate, disclosed that England's specialist schools continue to outperform from the non-specialists, with language colleges achieving the highest grades. However, while 65.1% of students at specialist language schools achieved five A*-C grades at GCSE in 2003, compared with 50.2% of those at the 700 non-specialists, the pass rate in foreign languages is dropping. Of the 2,188 specialist schools in England, only 200 concentrate on foreign languages. Only a dozen non-specialist schools are interested in becoming language colleges. A deterrent is the belief that achieving high academic standards is made more difficult.

(The Times, 16 February 2005)


Modern language teaching fading away

Boring GCSE courses are to blame for putting pupils off languages, according to the Qualifications and Curriculum Authority. As anxiety grows about the future of modern languages when they become optional for 14-year-olds in September 2004, the report urges exam boards to replace "uninteresting and irrelevant syllabuses". Teachers complain that they have to sell dreary French, German and Spanish courses about buying bus tickets and ice creams.

The report found that a third of schools had made languages optional, and in some schools fewer than a half of key stage 4 pupils were learning a language. The QCA blamed the exam boards for the dull courses. It said it had tried to persuade awarding bodies to include topics that are relevant to candidates and reflect their maturity.

(TES, 11 June 2004)


Heads have free choice for language diversity

Primary heads will no longer be restricted to Europe when choosing languages to offer pupils. Pupils aged seven and older will still have the right, from 2010, to lessons in any language. The change will give a greater role to community languages like Bengali, and will help schools struggling to find teachers fluent in French, Spanish or German.

Ministers hope the move will give schools the freedom to and flexibility to make the best use of the expertise in their local community. In London, the most commonly spoken languages by school pupils after English are Bengali, Punjabi and Gujarati.

(TES, 26 March, 2004)


The search for primary teachers with foreign languages skills

Primary teachers are to be asked about their hidden talents in foreign languages in the first step towards a huge teacher-training programme.

The Government wants all primary schools to offer children the opportunity to study a foreign language by 2010. But it has stopped short of making foreign languages compulsory in primary schools because of a lack of suitable teachers.

Ministers have now commissioned an 18-month, £120,000 study from Canterbury Christ Church University College, Manchester Metropolitan University and King's College London, to gauge the level of language skills and teaching in primary schools. Secondary schools will also be contacted to find out what support they could give to local primaries.

The Government expects headteachers to give existing primary teachers who want to train in languages the support and opportunity to do so. It has promised funds to develop teachers' skills.

It is also inviting local authorities to bid for funding to try out different ways of managing and extending language teaching. Between three and six authorities are expected to be chosen as pathfinders.

(TES, 21 March 2003)


Language test for primary children

Primary pupils are to have their modern language skills assessed before they start secondary school under Government plans to be published in December 2002. Education junior minister Baroness Catherine Ashton told MPs that the national languages strategy document would propose that pupils in their final primary year could have the option of being graded in a modern foreign language, and that this information should be passed to their secondary school.

The strategy aims to offer the option of languages from the age of seven upwards. The report is also expected to propose that hundreds of language assistants from France, Spain and Germany be hired to give language lessons to primary pupils, using cash earmarked for the 50,000 extra classroom assistants. However, the question of how much language teaching should be available for older teenagers - who will soon be able to drop languages at the age of 14 - is expected to be sidestepped. 

(TES, 6 December 2002)


Is language learning at crisis point?

A TES survey covering nearly 67,000 pupils, released in November 2002, suggests that more than half of England's secondary schools are poised to end compulsory languages from the age of 14. 29% of schools will make languages optional for 14-year-olds and a further 25% are considering doing so.

The survey also reveals a split by social class, fuelling fears that languages could soon become a middle class option as schools serving the poorest communities become less likely to make children study French, German or Spanish.

Extrapolating the findings of the 393 schools in the survey across the country would suggest that 1,866 of England's 3,457 state secondaries will make languages optional.

(TES, 22 November 2002)



Early immersion in French shows results

A daily partial immersion in French from the start of primary schooling has produced pupils with excellent accents and intonation at Walker Road primary school in Aberdeen - a far cry from the norm even at secondary level.

An analysis of the partial immersion project (now in its third year) by Professor Dick Johnstone of Stirling University, the country's leading foreign language researcher, shows strong support among pupils, parents and teachers for a unique experiment.

Some 80 pupils between P1 and P3 (aged 4 to 7) are learning part of the curriculum - often the expressive arts to begin with - through French with lessons delivered by two native speakers. 15% of time in P1 is in French, rising to 25% by P3.

Professor Johnstone's verdict, so far, is that pupils are quick to model their language on the two immersion teachers (ITs). "Their comprehension is usually quick and accurate and they do not seem phased by the speed at which the ITs talk. They generally seem relaxed yet concentrated and are happy to volunteer their own words and phrases in French."

(TESS, 15 November 2002)


QCA report delays compulsory foreign language lessons in primaries 

The introduction of compulsory foreign language lessons in primary schools would be unworkable despite widespread support from pupils, parents and teachers. Forcing all eight to 11-year-olds to learn a language would be impossible because of teacher shortages, a packed primary curriculum and opposition from primary heads according to report concluding the Qualifications and Curriculum Authority's two-year investigation.

Language teaching in primary schools has declined over the past five years. Britain is the only European country not making foreign language lessons at primary age compulsory.

(Independent, 1 August 2001)

The TES reported that the introduction of compulsory foreign languages at primary school is at least five years away because of the shortage of linguists and lack of space in the timetable. The QCA is arguing that more resources must be made available before languages can become part of the statutory curriculum.

(TES, 3 August 2001)



UK at bottom of languages class

Britains' command of languages other than their own is the worst in Europe by a considerable margin. In contrast more than half of continental Europeans can speak at least one foreign language and some two. 

The report Europeans and Languages reveals that 66% of the British population have absolutely no knowledge of any other language other than English. This was despite the fact that some 74% of Britons polled said that they thought learning a foreign language was useful. Some 41% of continental Europeans claim to be able to speak English.
More than 16,000 people were polled in December 2000 of whom at least 1,300 were based in the UK.

Only slightly better informed than the British were the Portuguese, where 56% of those polled said they only knew their native language. In Spain the figure was 53% and in France 51%. Almost 80% of Swedish, Danish, and Dutch people could speak English.

(The Guardian, 20 February 2001)



Call for foreign language strategy 
 

A national strategy is needed to tackle British complacency about learning foreign languages, according to NIACE, the National Institute of Continuing Adult Education. Its report, Divided by Language, shows the problem is particularly acute among white adults, only 11% of whom speak two other languages, compared with 45% of ethnic minorities.

The report was carried out to contribute to the now-published Nuffield Language Inquiry, which concluded that UK business is increasingly dependent on the "linguistic competence and goodwill" of people abroad.

The report coincides with the European Year of Languages, which runs throughout 2001. It notes wide variations between socio-economic groups. Among the ABs (professional groups), 65% of people speak more than one language, compared with just 28% of DEs (manual workers).

The research also found that 42% of people in England speak more than one language, compared with 53% in Wales and 31% in Scotland. The high Welsh figure is attributed to the priority given to the Welsh language in schools.

(TES, 12 January 2001)



Nuffield Inquiry on modern languages proposes adding language modules to the national literacy strategy

The Nuffield Inquiry, a two-year study into Britain's language skills by a team of 12 educationists and industrialists is urging ministers to introduce modern language teaching in all primary schools. The report criticises Britain's "deplorable monolingualism". The following key proposals were made in its May 2000 report:

  • All pupils to learn a new language from age seven by 2010
  • Add language modules to the national literacy strategy
  • Set up international primary schools - specialist schools to teach the majority of the curriculum in a foreign language
  • Secondary schools to provide more than just French
  • Make a foreign language a requirement for university entry and for vocational courses and compulsory for all 16 - 19-year-olds.
  • Attract more languages teachers. Teacher training should include the opportunity for trainees to develop linguistic and professional skills.
  • Produce national strategy to develop language capability
  • Appoint languages supremo to work with government departments, national agencies, employers and the public
  • Launch advertising campaign to raise the profile of languages
Alan Moys, secretary of the inquiry, quoted PG Wodehouse's The Luck of the Bodkins: "Into the face of the young man who sat on the terrace of the Hotel Magnifique at Cannes there had crept a look of furtive shame, the shifty hangdog look which announces that an Englishman is about to speak French."

When do pupils in other countries start learning a foreign language?
 
Age 6  Austria, Norway, Luxembourg 
Age 7  Italy 
Age 8 Spain, Liechtenstein 
Age 9  Greece, France 
Age 10  Denmark, Netherlands, Germany, Portugal 
Age 11  Iceland 

(TES, 12 May 2000)



Modern languages in primary schools are being hampered by teachers' lack of time, training and subject knowledge

Modern languages in primary schools are being hampered by teachers' lack of time, training and subject knowledge, according to the interim evaluation of a Government project looking at 18 schemes.

The Good Practice Project was set up last September by the Department for Education and Employment to examine a variety of primary language projects reflecting the diversity of current provision and teaching models in England and Wales.

A number of obstacles were identified including a shortage of time for languages and a lack of continuity and progression when children move from primary to secondary.

The project will run until March 2001 and is part of a DfEE initiative to develop and encourage early language learning being run by the Centre for Information on Language Teaching and Research. The interim findings will be reported in September 2000.

One of the schemes being looked at is the Sheffield multilingual city project which encourages primaries and early years centres to teach additional languages. Sheffield is planning Britain's first city language policy which will unite schools, universities, businesses and the community. Many three-year-olds in the city learn French, German and Spanish at nursery. Sheffield Age Concern runs a basic Spanish course.

(TES, 7 July 2000)


Foreign language study declining in Wales

Only one in 10 pupils is studying for a modern foreign language in some Welsh schools. Statistics from Estyn, the Welsh inspection body, show that the overall number of GCSE foreign language candidates is continuing to plummet.

Five years ago, 55% of Welsh 16-year-olds sat a language GCSE. In 2000 it dropped to 44% and in 2001 it will be 42%.

Officials are preparing a national strategy to encourage the study of languages beyond 14, through improved teaching, making it more fun and stressing its relevance and benefits.

The introduction of compulsory Welsh at key stage 4 is partly responsible for the fall in languages' candidates.

(TES, 7 July 2000)

Click here for more information on literacy issues in Wales



Case for classics debunked

The claim of classicists that Latin is good training for the mind is being challenged by a German study. Berlin psychologists have carried out a study by following German school children in Bavaria before the children made a modern language choice, two years into learning Latin and four years into learning Latin. (Latin is compulsory in Bavaria.)

The results of the pupils learning Latin in intelligence tests and, more specifically, in verbal activities showed not the slightest difference when compared to those who had not done Latin but had learned a modern foreign language.

Other tests looking at the effects of learning Latin on mathematical, logical and deductive thinking, grammar, spelling, idiomatic usage, comprehension, and students' ability to articulate ideas also showed little difference.

A follow-up study tested the thesis that Latin can help with learning other foreign languages. Psychologist Elsbeth Stern of the Max Planck Institute for Human Development and Ludwig Haag, a psychologist at the University of Erlangen in Nuremberg and former Latin teacher, looked at German university students studying Spanish from scratch. 

Students with four or more years of French at school made fewer grammatical errors and fewer efforts with Spanish vocabulary than those with four or more years of Latin.

(TES, 29 June 2001)



Pupils to gain credits for speaking languages

Pupils could receive grades for languages, similar to those given for music, whether they have learned them in or out of school under proposals being considered by the Government.

Children who learn an instrument in school or privately progress from grades 1 to 8 getting a pass, merit or distinction at each level.

Under the plan, announced in the Lords by education minister Baroness Ashton, pupils would gain credit for speaking languages such as Hindi, Urdu or Greek which are not always available as exam subjects.

(TES, 25 January 2002)



Lack of teachers means no compulsory languages at primary level

Foreign languages will be introduced in primary schools by 2012 but they will not be compulsory, unlike everywhere else in the European Union. Moreover, the Green Paper 14-19: extending opportunities, raising standards means that from 2004 they will cease to be compulsory at secondary school from 14. Ministers admitted that plans depend on recruiting more language teachers.

In February 2002 the ambassadors of Germany, Spain, Italy and France called for action to improve language teaching in Britain.

(TES, 15 February 2002)

German teachers told to learn English at their own cost

Primary teachers in Germany have been told they must attend courses in English lasting up to 18 months, in their spare time and often at their own expense, as part of a drive to teach all eight-year-olds a foreign language from next year.

(TES, 1 March 2002)

 



France's approach to learning foreign languages
  • In state schools children start learning a modern foreign language at the age of 11-12. (The languages chosen may be English, German or Spanish).
  • Studying English is obligatory at the baccalaureate level between 17 and 18.
  • For entry into the prestigious technical schools, the grandes ecoles, English counts for 25% of the marks in the exams.
(Guardian, 30 April 2002)


Six-year-olds cope with two languages

Children as young as six cope well when learning to read and write in two languages, new research has shown.

London University researcher Charmian Kenner found that bilingual children learning different scripts became skilled at spotting the differences between letters.

Six Year 1 children who were learning Arabic, Chinese or Spanish took part in the project.

Dr Kenner said: "Teachers could introduce a bit of Japanese and French, to help children realise that there are different kinds of system. Six-year-olds are highly capable of learning about many different facets of writing."

(TES, 28 June 2002)

 

Donate Online

Bookshop

National Year of Reading logo

 

The National Literacy Trust is an independent charity and relies on voluntary contributions. If you have found our website useful, please consider making a donation. Every penny helps.
 



Copyright © National Literacy Trust 2008
Unless otherwise specified, all material on this website may be used for non-commercial purposes, on condition that the source is acknowledged. The NLT is not responsible for the content of external websites.
National Literacy Trust is a registered charity, no. 1116260 and a company limited by guarantee, no. 5836486. Registered in England and Wales.
Registered address: 68 South Lambeth Road, London SW8 1RL